Your Cart



Are each of your baseballs individually hand-painted?

Our themed, collectible baseballs, baseball cards, footballs, fine art prints and card sets are high-quality printed replicas of original paintings by our company founder, Emily M. Wolfson. Select hand-painted originals are now available in baseball and fine art formats.

Do your items arrive gift-wrapped & ready?

We are very proud of our packaging! Each of our themed collectible baseballs comes in an acrylic cube, within a printed gift box.

They are immediately gift ready, but we also have additional baseball displays and gift packaging options available.

Our collectible, designed footballs come directly in their ship box. This box can be presented with the football, as the football is nestled in crinkle paper and presents like a gift.

Our commemorative, engraved baseball bats are shipped directly from the engraver who puts them in a plastic bag to protect them, and then places them into a sturdy shipper tube.

Our baseball-themed collectible bottle openers and baseball stadium coasters each come in attractive clear packaging with the Unforgettaballs® logo.

Large display pieces for multiple baseballs ship directly from the manufacturer and are carefully packaged in foam and cardboard for protection during shipping.

How long will it take to receive my order?

Your order will ship within 48 hours of receipt, it will then take approximately 7 days to reach you if you live in the continental US (Closer to 5 days if you are on the east coast, and closer to 7 days if you are shipping to the west coast).

What is your return policy?

Our first priority is to make sure you are happy with your order! Please contact us if you have any issues regarding returns, exchanges, or problems.

What is the Collector's Club & how do I join?

The Unforgettaballs® Baseball Collector's Club was created to offer special discounts & exclusive offers to our baseball enthusiasts and repeat buyers. To join, simply purchase the membership for a one-time fee of $50. You will get to select a free baseball, and get instant access to your club member discounted rates. Read more details here!

Will any of your retired designs ever make a comeback?

Sadly, if a design is retired it means that it is sold out and out of print.

I'm a store owner interested in carrying your products. Do you wholesale?

Yes! We'd be honored for your store to carry our collectible, themed baseballs. Simply review our wholesale agreement & submit your application here.

Can you create custom-painted baseball designs upon request?

At this time we are not taking on any custom commission work. It is the problem of being a small business, never enough hours in the day!